This
third grade class is entirely made up of African American students, many of who
are really struggling with reading. Something happened this week, on Election
Day, that I will never forget. The teacher, Ms. Randle was working with four
boys who particularly struggle with reading. As they were reading, Ms. Randle
grew frustrated because they kept getting stuck on their site words. (The
students are expected to know site words like the back of their hands). After
one of the students got stuck on a site word the fourth or fifth time, she
stopped them and gave them a serious talk. She told them that it is absolutely
imperative that they read every single night in order to improve their reading
skills. She told them that people build jail sells based on how many African
American third grade males cannot read by the time they move onto fourth grade.
She told them that they had to work extra hard because they were black and they
were males. She explained that she also had to work extra hard, being a black
female, and this meant they all had two strikes against them. She then told
them that she was not mad at them or yelling at them, although her tone was
very stern and serious. She told them she was being honest with them because
she loved them, and she wanted the best for them. By the end of her speech, I
had tears in my eyes.
Being an education major, I have
learned about how the amount of jail cells that are built is dependent on the
amount of black boys who cannot read by the end of third grade. I was very
disturbed when I heard this for the first time, but nothing can compare to
hearing a dedicated, desperate teacher tell this reality to her students who
are prone to this unjust future. No eight-year-old should ever have to hear
that jail could very well be in their future. However, I do not blame Ms.
Randle for being so candid with her students. Some may argue that the Ms.
Randle’s speech was too much for third graders to hear, but I think she did the
right thing. She was motivating and pushing them with something that is so real
and pertinent in their lives. This fear that she instilled in them could be
what saves them from being locked up in their future.
I have grown to adore these young
students. They are charismatic, curious, sweet, and extremely funny. I am so
heartbroken to even imagine that these good, innocent children may end up in
jail solely based on our corrupt education system as well as our corrupt
justice system. Our country desperately needs justice, particularly racial justice,
but I jus cannot help but feel hopeless in regards to these justices in the
light of the presidential election.
Thank you for sharing this heartbreaking and eye-opening experience you witnessed. To hear the racism within our education system and justice system voiced so palpably and desperately shows just how pervasive it is. I attended a majority-black middle and high school, and I remember at first being shocked and confused by such vast disparities between the reading levels of many African American students and many white students. In my high school, there were a large chunk of students, mostly of color, and, in my particular high school, mostly African American, that had never passed the 6th grade reading level. It is no wonder that drop-out rates are so high for this demographic; I can't imagine how much more difficult and frustrating 10th, 11th, or 12th grade would be when coming from a 6th grade reading level.
ReplyDeleteThis is an extremely alarming statistic and correlation. I am at a loss for words that someone was able to figure out the correlation between reading proficiency from third grade with how many cells to construct. It makes sense that people would try to figure such out considering the profitability of jails and correctional facilities in the stock market. Nonetheless, I am utterly amazed at this and can't even begin to describe or articulate how it must feel considering my school had a very limited number of African-American students (my graduating class of 73 had 2) so this is foreign to me even though I have a fair amount of family friends who are involved with jails and correctional facilities.
ReplyDeleteI had no idea about this correlation between third grade reading level and rates in prison. There are many problems with our current education system including the very low rate of social mobility. The result of a student not learning to read by third grade in a school where students live with a higher economic status are not endanger of going to prison. Many schools provide access to tutoring or individual help at a price that can be afforded by these wealthier parents. Unfortunately, in schools with less resources and funding, the realities of not learning to read by third grade are drastic and devastating. Not learning to read by third grade for these students indicates that they have a high probability of going to jail. Students may not have access to books or help from their parents who may be working in these schools so practicing reading without resources may prove extremely difficult for these students.
ReplyDeleteThis post really hits home with me because I work at Snowden School and also have heard this similar talk given to my brother from my mom. The statistic you've stated is so so so true and such a scary thing to know while working in a school such as Snowden. I see these children 4 days out of the week and all I do is wish the best for them. It's so disheartening to know that some of the children I have grown to know and love may not have the best future because they struggle in reading. This is just one of the many problems with our educational system which is why working in education has become my passion. Hearing the conversation my mom had with my younger brother and knowing how hurt she was to even have that conversation with him broke my heart even more. Our society is so messed up, I can't even begin to explain. However, this is something that parents and adults have to warn their children and students about. It definitely cannot be ignored. These conversations are brutally honest and are a necessity for African Americans of all ages living in today's society.
ReplyDelete