This morning I read an
article titled “Dear ‘Persecuted’ College Conservative: You Are Not Oppressed.”
The article is in response to another article titled “Check Your Liberal
Privilege.” The article I read attempts to express why it is so incendiary for
conservatives, or perhaps just non-liberals, to draw connections between their
discomfort in openly expressing their views vs. “being a member of a historically oppressed group.” While some viewpoints are definitely promoted in college
environments while others are more often discouraged, particularly in a liberal
arts environment, it is ridiculous to undermine the experiences of “legacies of violence, intimidation, and hatred,”
especially when this legacy is very much alive.
The article points out
much of what we’ve discussed in our class—we’ve been learning history from the
white perspective and mostly about the white experience. This is not to say
only white people are conservatives, but it is important to recognize that our
society is based around the people of privilege, and it is those same people of
privilege that are offended when their opinion isn’t continuously celebrated.
The article continues to
eventually express sympathy for any kind of perceived silencing of the
conservative voice, but still, the author goes on to try to explain why
liberals are speaking out so loudly. The author explains that conservative
(also calling out whites, men, and heterosexuals) views and issues have been
repeatedly at the forefront of our society. Liberals or their views/issues, the
author says, “have not only been ignored, but actively and violently silenced
for just as many centuries.”
All in all the article
sums up to agree that there needs to be healthier dialogues taking place.
People of privilege on both sides of the equation need to use said privilege to
dismantle the misunderstandings of both viewpoints. I feel like many of us
would agree with this and have been arguing for this throughout the semester. I
think most of us agree that in order to move forward we must all be able to
discuss openly and honestly with one another. But this is more difficult than
we want it to be. It means listening to viewpoints that are contrary to what we
believe in and trying to understand another perspective. Our views become so innate
to who we are that we have a tendency to give up or shut out anything that
departs from this. And while this article is aimed at conservatives, its
important for everyone to remember to take the time to understand why certain viewpoints exist, what the
limits of these are, and what brought them about in the first place. There is a
backstory and history to everything and that shouldn’t be ignored when trying
to move forward.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/dear-persecuted-college-conservative_us_584a4179e4b0151082221a02
First, amen!
ReplyDeleteSecond, you point out the key thing missing in our current moment. Yes, all white people are privileged, but are the ones seeking to use said privilege for good actually doing it? For example, if a white person says that they support civil rights and equality, they march, protest, stand in solidarity with other races. But when it matters most for them to use said privilege, they don't. All of us can think of the most recent example of this.
My point being that there is distinction between one's words and their actions. I don't want anyone to think that this only applies to white people, but for this post that was my focus.